RDP 2003-09: Housing Leverage in Australia Appendix A: Income Imputation and Results

As discussed in Section 2.2, the nature of the missing data leaves us with the need to impute income for three separate types of missing cases. For Type I individuals we impute total gross financial year income. For Type II individuals we impute gross financial year wage and salary income and add this imputed income to their reported gross financial year non-wage and salary income. For Type III individuals we impute gross financial year non-wage and salary income and add this imputed income to their reported gross financial year wage and salary income. Table Al contains all the relevant results.

In all cases, missing values are imputed using the predictive mean matching (PMM) method outlined in Little (1988). In the first stage this involves estimating a regression on the variable to be imputed for individuals without missing values – in our case income. Next the model with the highest R2 is used to predict the income of individuals with missing values. For every missing value we find the record with the nearest predicted value. The actual value of this ‘donor’ is then imputed for the missing value. The advantages of using the PMM method over other single imputation methods, such as simply imputing the conditional mean obtained from a regression, are that it ensures that only feasible values of the variable are imputed, and that a random error component is introduced so that imputed values have a similar variance to the reported values (ISER 2002).

Table A1: Income Imputation Results
I Total income ('000)   II Wage income ('000)   III Non-wage income ('000)
Age 1.6***   Age 0.8***   Age 0.08***
Age squared −0.15***   Age squared −0.01***      
VIC −0.3   VIC −1.2**   VIC 0.6
QLD −1.4*   QLD 0.0   QLD 0.0
SA −2.4**   SA −1.2*   SA −0.8
WA −0.9   WA −2.4***   WA 1.3**
ACT 6.3***   ACT 4.8***   ACT −1.5
Make ends meet 3.9***   Make ends meet 2.1***   Make ends meet 0.9***
Socio-economic 1.0***   Socio-economic 0.1***   Socio-economic  
Has disability 2.3***   Business income −16.0***   Business income 20.9***
Lone person 7.9***   Govt benefit −5.1***   Govt benefit 2.6***
Group household 6.7***   Receives interest 1.2***   Receives interest 4.1***
Sole parent, dependant children 6.8***   Receives rent 4.4***   Receives rent 4.5***
  Receives dividends 2.5***   Receives dividends 1.0**
Sole parent, no dependant children 4.4**   Non-metropolitan −1.9***   Age pensioner −2.3***
  Inner-city 1.5***   Receives royalties 3.9
Persons in h'hold −1.4***   Union member 5.9***   Union member −1.9***
Employed 13.0***   Employed 11.6***   Employed −4.2***
Retired −7.6***   Retired −10.6***   Retired 4.3***
Home duties −6.0***   Spouse's income 0.0***   Spouse's income 0.1***
Multifamily home −3.7*   Multifamily home −3.6**   Student −1.7
  Household head 9.9***   Household head 6.2***
No of bedrooms 0.8***   Has disability 1.5***   Health 0.2
Home's condition −1.1***   Home's condition −0.8***   Home's condition −0.3
Home value 0.03***   Home value 0.004***   Home value 0.004***
No of children 1.4***         No of children 0.3*
Married 8.1***   Education level 2 −10.9***   Never married 3.9***
Separated 4.7***   Education level 3 −11.1***   Separated 3.9***
De facto 10.0***   Education level 4 −11.6***   De facto 2.3***
Divorced 4.9***   Education level 5 −10.7***   Divorced 4.8***
Widowed 8.5***   Widowed 4.4*   Widowed 1.8*
Adjusted R2 0.32   Adjusted R2 0.46   Adjusted R2 0.204
RMSE $26,000   RMSE $19,000   RMSE $20,500

Note: ***, ** and * represent significants at 1, 5 and 10 per cent levels.