Transcript of Question & Answer Session The Role of Research in Monetary Policymaking
Renée Fry-McKibbin
Monetary Policy Board Member
Conference in Honour of Andy Stoeckel – The Changing Global Economy, Centre for Applied Macroeconomic Analysis, Crawford School of Public Policy, Australian National University
– Canberra
(Panel introductions and panel discussion)
… Simple descriptive stats still need some explanation behind them that goes beyond what you can easily share on whatever social media platform is being used. So, I think were still grappling, I think, with that public engagement in the kind of rest of government, and Im sure political classes would point to that as an issue when youre trying to have complex policy discussions and get ahead of public concerns to steer things in a helpful policy direction.
Renée Fry-McKibbin
Well, I think its really important to draw on universities and have conferences like this where we can really do deep dives into particular questions that we have and bring together public servants. I think academics can actually do research that people who work in the public service cant do, because they are constrained by what the politicians want and by budgets and priorities, and so on.
So, I think that us as academics and our students and the questions that were asking and our contribution to commentary is really important in trying to steer conversation and public understanding of issues into right directions.
(Panel discussion)
Renée Fry-McKibbin
I think there always needs to be a human element in the research that were doing as well and making sure … I mean, AI can answer whatever question, but its really in the questions that we have as researchers and people who are interested in public policy thats going to matter and its going to drive where things go.
And I think thats fundamental. And I think as individuals taking a longer-term perspective and building up our own reputations in terms of focusing on high quality and making sure that everything is done correctly, we know theres a lot of AI slop out there, but I think so all of our students are going to need to be really good at networking and talking about their research with other people so that their ideas and their, I guess, the importance of their questions and the relevance of their questions are really paramount.
Dr Jenny Gordon
So, when Australia went through its major reform period in the 80s, you actually had academics play a major role in talking and educating the Australian public. So, how do you see that role with media? Is it easier, is it harder these days?
(Panel discussion)
Renée Fry-McKibbin
I think we addressed this a little in the RBA review around communication and this public panel and us having public engagement as Board members is a part of that and its up to the institutions to find ways to communicate with people and to make sure their message is getting across and I think the RBA is doing really well in that in terms of Governor Bullocks press conferences after every single decision thats made, because even a no change is still a decision and her being able to explain to people and answer peoples questions is really important. It would be really nice to go back to a world where no one cared about economics, because there used to be a time when no one cared about economics, but now they do because it affects everybodys lives and it is a tricky time.
So, it is up to us to communicate better and to try to engage in the new mediums that we can engage with, the social media and other types of messaging. And so, this was my first public presentation as a Monetary Policy Board member, but I had the opportunity last year to go to Western Australia with some of the Board members and the deputy governor to learn about whats happening in the Western Australian economy and we got to interact with people from community groups and chambers of commerce and things and just have those one-on-one conversations and I think thats really important to be … Obviously, you cant go out and speak to every single person, but just to be going out into the community in different ways than we have before and I think for me as well, it was a great opportunity to learn about the other parts of the economy that I dont see on a day-to-day basis. So, I think that communication is really, really important.
Dr Jenny Gordon
I think thats a really good point about think tanks and that we dont have an awful lot of them in Australia. Im associated with a few of them.
But we actually have a lot of economic consultancy firms, and CIE was one of them, right? And so, at my time at CIE, you relied a lot on what was going on in the research community to harvest, and we saw ourselves a bit as the ones who would pull together the research and harvest.
So, itd be good to get your perspectives on what is that role of that consultancy industry. Should that be more … Instead of government relying on consultancies to do that, should that be more in-house?
Renée Fry-McKibbin
I think you need a mix. Sometimes you might need to have experts in certain areas for a very short period of time, and you can draw on consultancies or academics at particular times. Other times you might need more in-house type of people who can do that. I guess its about transparency and people knowing what peoples backgrounds are and what theyre working on and making sure that there are proper processes for that.
(Panel discussion)
Dr Jenny Gordon
So, Im going to open it up to the audience. Ill just ask them one more question. So, think hard and put your hand up, and we have a roving mic here, so Ill just give you a moment, because I just want to ask about one of the challenges that weve got these days is this kind of loss of trust in expertise and part of it is because the experts know that whatever answer theyve got, whatever their research is, they know the errors, they know the potential that theyre wrong, and theyre always saying, the sort of the boundaries of this, of confidence are such.
And so theyre not saying, "This is the answer," with the kind of conviction that the general public might feel is needed and so you had this undermining of expertise so, just how do you think we could go about countering that?
(Panel discussion)
Renée Fry-McKibbin
Yeah, I guess having been an academic, well, I am an academic, but now Im sitting now in a policy position, you dont have all the information and I guess our job is to try to bring together all of the information that we have and to come up with the best conclusions that we can with our best judgment that we have, but to also try to communicate that as clearly as we possibly can, especially in these uncertain times. And its easy for people to just pick up on the things that affect them most. But yeah, I guess all we can do is try to present that uncertainty and try to communicate that we have considered a whole lot of things and well change our minds if necessary, if new information comes to us.
Adrian Rawlins
Yeah, my names Adrian Rawlins. Im with Business News, so Im part of the media diaspora. So, its been really interesting to hear the conversation here. Just a couple of quick observations, if I may.
One is just, because Ive also spent time in a policymakers office over the journey, and a couple of the things that sort of struck me was, A, that the sense to which an idea can have its moment, and it can have a particular salience at a time which isnt particularly obvious to the person who works on the idea.
And so it seems that the idea of, as a researcher, presenting and developing ideas and proposals, knowing that they might not hit at the right time for the person whos developing it, but it might have its moment at some point down the track. Youre just not knowing exactly when that is and what the circumstances in which that might happen isnt necessarily foreseeable.
Also, thinking about the media, theres obviously elements of the media which have an agenda, and I think itd be naive to sort of think, "Right, we can just pitch up a policy idea in this environment and think itll be treated on its merits necessarily." So, I suppose my question to the audience and to the panel is, to what extent should, in anticipating where interest might go and where the research might go, to what extent should it also be thinking about that broader political context of the work youre doing?
Renée Fry-McKibbin
Oh, well, I guess I can start. I guess ideas and having their moments and not being quite the right time is what academics are all about. Were all working on different things, maybe sometimes theyre relevant, sometimes theyre not to current policy, but when were needed, were going to be there.
In terms of the media, I guess as an academic, you just want to be as honest as you can and try to put things out in your own words, your own perspective, and hope that some of that will filter through. And I guess theres not much you can do about particular biases, but hopefully reasonable people who are interested in evaluating both sides of particular problems or questions are able to do that.
(Panel discussion)
Renée Fry-McKibbin
I think for me now, being a new policymaker, listening to other sides of arguments is actually really important, not just to know what other people are saying, but also to challenge your own thinking to make sure that youre on the right track. “Have I missed anything?” Because its easy for people to have a strong opinion on something thats happened, but you do need to think about it in a little more depth when were actually making decisions that affect people.
Questioner
I was previously a researcher, but now working in the government. And I wonder, this is more in relation to the publish or perish culture, and if you look at the broader literature, there will probably be quite little on small countries like Australia. Why, when we need to use research for policy advice, we may need something that is extremely relevant for Australia. So, how can we address this issue? Thanks.
Renée Fry-McKibbin
Yong, have you not read my papers? Theres lots of people in here who work on small countries like Australia.
(Panel discussion)
Renée Fry-McKibbin
I think that Australia is doing amazing anyway. The Australian Bureau of Statistics have put together some amazing databases, and theres so much amazing coordination across, like the ATO, and you do more of this data than I do, but theres a lot of research thats coming out thats based on Australian data recently thats being published in the top journals, and its really quite extraordinary. So, we have some really special data that we can use, as well as some really interesting questions from us.
So, I think that we should be really proud to be from Australia and working on Australian topics. And I think that if you can find those questions and the data sources that other countries cant get, then you can publish them in the top journals and not worry about perishing and not publishing.
Questioner
I was really interested in your comments on the liaison program that the bank runs, and the idea that you could sort of use that to leverage real-time data into policymaking and forecasting. And so, just as a specific example, weve had a spate of companies reporting job cuts in the recent weeks, and so Im just sort of wondering to what extent is that being picked up in the liaison program, and to what extent does that inform the forecast, given, as you said, theres this tension between, or this trying to sort of reconcile these two sort of objectives of monetary policy, the inflation and the labour market?
Renée Fry-McKibbin
We get a lot of information from the liaison program coming up to the Board, and its one of the pieces of information that I personally find really insightful and informative, because its telling us things that havent made it into the aggregate statistics yet. They havent made it to GDP, they havent made it into inflation, havent made it into unemployment. We do find that is a really useful tool.
And Im pretty sure pretty much everyone is looking at that, but how it goes into the forecast, the forecasts are made by the staff and not so much us, so theyve got their black box that we see a little bit later.
But I know that they do take the liaison program extremely seriously as this is whats happening to the economy now, and this is what people are, companies are thinking about doing next and so thats really valuable for us.
Nasteho Said
Nasteho Said from Bloomberg. Im wondering what you think of New Zealands system where each Board member identifies their vote and also speaks a little bit about their thinking behind it. Is that something Australia should head towards at all?
Renée Fry-McKibbin
We didnt recommend it in the RBA Review, but it is another model. Being on the Board now, I can see its attractions, in that if you do want to have a voice, and because what we do now is confidential, if you do want to have a voice, then you would be able to be more free to speak. You might not have your reasoning behind your decisions made. So, I can see an argument for it, but we decided not to go down that route, I guess, just because there were …
You can have too much noise around decisions as well.
So, we just decided to allow the disagreements amongst the Board to come through, through the publication of the number of people who voted for a decision or who didnt, rather than going down too far into the nitty-gritty of those reasons. I dont know.
Dr Jenny Gordon
So, were almost at time, but I might just ask each of our three panellists if theyve got last wise words for how to improve the academic policy interface.
Renée Fry-McKibbin
I was going to say, come and join places like CAMA. We focus on macroeconomic research. We have 240 research associates from all over the world. Some of them are here, and we share our research in really efficient ways with common working papers and really targeted conferences, both here and in other places. And we have really great networks, and we are all very friendly.
(Panel continues and concludes)