Panel Participation Panel Participation at the ASIC Annual Forum
Moderator
With our first panel discussion of the day, which will look appropriately at the state of the economy. Sarah Court will rejoin us on stage to offer ASIC's perspective, joined by Reserve Bank Governor, Michele Bullock, Danielle Wood, the Chair of the Productivity Commission, and Leah Weckert, the CEO and Managing Director of Coles.
And while they make their way to the stage, let's take a look at the focus of this panel. Australia's economy is being reshaped by rapid technological change, evolving markets, geopolitical uncertainty, and continuing financial pressure on households and businesses. This session will examine the economic forces and structural shifts influencing consumers, businesses, government, and Australia's future prosperity.
[Panel discussion continues]
Moderator
Governor Bullock, I will ask you now, how does the Monetary Policy Board see the balance of the risks facing the Australian economy, and what are the developments that you are watching most closely as potential sources of disruption? The Treasurer mentioned oil prices. What's top of your agenda?
Michele Bullock
A lot of things are at the top of my agenda. So, as you know, we raised interest rates. We've raised them five times, 125 basis points since the beginning of the year. One thing I wanted to make extremely clear is that it's not just a response to oil prices. We already had inflation above target in the latter half of last year and early this year, and we'd already started raising interest rates before the Middle East conflict started, and oil prices started to rise. They've made it worse. They've made it more challenging. We can't offset the oil price rises. It's quite true that interest rates do not address that issue. But what we can do with interest rates is we can decrease demand and ease the pressure, which is coming from excess demand on the economy. That's what the interest rate rises are designed to do.
Now, in terms of the risks, I think what we feel at the moment is that the risks on inflation are still skewed to the upside, and there's a number of reasons for that. The first is oil prices. The Treasurer referred to our assumptions about oil prices in our forecasts. And what we do in a mechanical way here is we don't forecast oil prices, we take the futures curve for oil prices, and that sees oil prices basically coming down. But one thing we've seen since this whole thing started was that expectations for oil prices to come down are unfulfilled. They've just been continually staying elevated. So there's a risk that even though we are sort of assuming that oil prices will start to ease and that will start to take pressure off headline inflation, there's actually a risk that that won't happen. So that's the first risk.
The second risk is that we do have accelerated demand driven by this AI boom and data centers. And I know there's sort of a bit of a societal backlash going on here, not just here, overseas as well. But nevertheless, there is a lot of expenditure going on here, and this is adding to demand and pressure on resources at a time that we don't really have space to absorb it. So that's another risk on the upside.
And the third risk on the upside is inflation expectations. We're getting just these little inklings from our liaison program when we talk to businesses that they're thinking, "You know what? Maybe 3 per cent, 3.5 per cent is the new normal for inflation." If that gets ingrained in people's thinking, in businesses' thinking, and consumers' and households' thinking, then it's going to be much harder to bring inflation back down to target at 2.5 per cent. Why do we want inflation back down there? We want it there because when it's down there, when it's sort of around 2, 2.5 per cent, it's in the background of people's decisions. It's not impacting... At the moment, as you know, everyone is just focused on inflation, and that detracts from sensible investment decisions. It detracts from consumers and households being able to make sensible decisions. So this is a reason we really – so this risk here at the moment is important that we don't have inflation expectations ingrained.
Now, having said all that, there are some downside risks that we're also focused on. One is the housing market. Now, monetary policy does work through housing, partly through housing. Part of the impact of higher interest rates is it lowers demand for housing loans, and it lowers demand for many of the goods and services that go along with the housing market. The housing market obviously has declined much further than that, and partly that will be due to some of the tax changes that are going on, but also just the general uncertainty in the community. Everything's just AI, geopolitics, conflicts in the Middle East and Ukraine. It's just all very uncertain. So I think all these things are having an impact. So that's sort of a downside thing that we haven't forgotten about. We are watching very closely because that will potentially offset some of those upside risks. But they're the key things that we're looking at.
Moderator
So a lot of risks from the RBA governor.
Michele Bullock
Yes.
[Panel discussion continues]
Moderator
Just moving back to the theme of the forum, the waves of change, I'm interested to hear from all of you what you think those waves are and what you think will have the biggest impact. Which big wave should we be fearing the most or most excited about? Is it geopolitics? Is it demographics? Is it technology? Is it climate change? Michele, what are you keeping an eye on in terms of these waves of change?
Michele Bullock
So I do think the technology wave is the one that is... Because it brings opportunities, but as we've already heard, it also brings risks. And so we've got to make sure that we're, the theme is trying to stay ahead of the wave. I don't know if we're going to succeed in that.
But from a financial stability perspective and from the perspective of some of the consumer stuff that Sarah spoke about, I think we do need to be very conscious of some of the risks that are coming with the technology without disenabling it, without trying to hold it back too much because it is the hope for productivity. So we do need to do that. So I think that's really important.
But my other issue, I guess it's a more general point, would be that ever since COVID, we have had a series of what I would call supply shocks. They are shocks to the supply side of the economy. First we had COVID, then we had the Russian invasion of Ukraine, then we had the trade. You might have forgotten about this. We've got a trade war tariff thing going on as well. We had that, and that's still going. We have, obviously now, the Middle East conflict. We've got all these supply shocks. Climate change is another one. They're all hitting, and they all hit, and then they don't completely go away. They all hang around, and that makes it very challenging for the economies. And it's not just us, it's around the world. But it makes it challenging for us. It makes it challenging for a central bank because we've got to control inflation in the face of supply shocks, but it also makes it more challenging for others. It makes it more challenging for governments to deal with all of these shocks that are coming in. How do they address those in terms of their own spending priorities, their own infrastructure priorities?
One of the things, for example, that came out of COVID and has only been strengthened by issues to do with the trade, and the tariffs issues, and the Middle East is supply chain risks. We went through a period up until COVID where the imperative for businesses was to minimise frictions in supply chains. Just-in-time supplies. You buy from the cheapest, you produce what you produce most efficiently, and you buy from others. People are rethinking that now.
And I'd have to say, actually, I think the response has been reasonably positive. We have been very pleasantly surprised, I'd have to say, by the way the world economy and the supply chains responded to the trade issues and to this most recent issue with the conflict in the Middle East. The supply chains have responded. They have worked, and I think that shows that we can learn and we can change our behaviors and the way our economies work a little bit in order to adapt.
So having said all that negative stuff, I'm actually reasonably positive that we will get the benefits of the productivity and that the world economy will manage to adapt, but it doesn't mean – it's going to be a bumpy ride, unfortunately.
[Panel discussion continues]
Moderator
Well, speaking of resilience, I think that is one point of positivity about this whole discussion. I think humans and Australians particularly are very resilient. You mentioned toilet paper gate. I, of course, remember it, but it's not at the front of my mind. You move on with your life, and you start dealing with the next challenge, the next problem, which is what we were discussing. Sarah, is there a danger in that to forgetting very quickly some of the challenges we're facing because we're already dealing with the next one?
Sarah Court
Yeah. Well, I guess that's right. I mean, I think it is good that we're resilient and that we move on. I think one of the things that I think about a lot, certainly since I've been at ASIC and taking up the new role in terms of memories, things being forgotten quickly, is all of the lessons of the Financial Services Royal Commission that we worked our way through five or six years ago, and that's one of the reasons I think that we talk a lot at ASIC about just that getting the basics right so that the world has moved on a lot since then. In fact, the financial system in some ways is almost unrecognisable. But having said that, there are still lessons to be learned and maintained all the way through.
I think one of the other reflections is listening to Leah's talk about what customers are used to and expect. I think one of the other things that we're thinking about a bit at the moment, I think that the financial industry is thinking about, and it comes back to my sort of scams and fraud point, is that we've spent a lot of time sort of designing a system to remove all friction so that payments can be instantaneous, everything can be very efficient. Nobody wants to sort of pause for a moment or so as a transaction happens. I think we are slowly, or maybe not so slowly, moving into a world where consumers are accepting some frictions in the way that they do business.
I know certainly my own bank, when you try to make a new payment, all sorts of things pop up, say, "Are you sure? Are you absolutely sure? We're going to hold your money for a couple of days." And I think we now recognize that that is important, and if you think about one of the other major waves that we're facing, we've already touched upon it, which is the sort of the growing cyber-related risks from frontier AI models and the requirement for sort of far more intensive and responsive patching, as opposed to sort of waiting every 24 hours or something. I think things might have to happen instantaneously.
I suspect that that's part of a new wave of being as well, is that consumers are going to start sort of appreciating that there may not be some things immediately or instantly available as those kind of issues are dealt with on an urgent basis. So it's almost slightly ironic in some ways that we're almost going, we may by through necessity have to go full circle.
Moderator
Michele, you have thoughts?
Michele Bullock
It's an interesting point, both points. And I think what we're thinking about here now is that risk is coming back into the equation, whereas efficiency was... But I wouldn't say we're going to go full circle. I think it's a risk-based approach.
So certainly in the payment system, I think the issue is, yes, frictionless, instantaneous payments. Some circumstances, perhaps maybe not a good idea. Other circumstances, absolutely fine. So I think it, and Leah was talking about diversifying a bit. So you're not going to diversify dramatically. You're going to identify where you think the risks lie, presumably, and you're going to try and adapt to address those risks. For others, you might be prepared to take a bit more risk. So I think it's actually interesting that risk is coming back into the conversation with businesses, and they're thinking about how to balance that efficiency and risk.
[Panel discussion continues]
Moderator
Michele, as someone who has attended many of your press conferences, I know that you like economic data. So this question from the audience might be a good one for you. If you could spend a week living on the average Australian household budget, what do you think would surprise you most about the economy that might not show up in the economic data?
Michele Bullock
So we actually do quite a lot of liaison with businesses, but we also do a lot of liaison with organisations that deal with things like household debt, people who've got debt problems. ACOSS, we talk to ACOSS, we talk to a number of organisations, Food Bank, those sorts of things. So, I don't know if it would surprise me, and I actually think that the average Australian household budget is not where we should be worrying. It's the people who are struggling towards the bottom end, and they're typically renters, and they're typically on low incomes. In an inflationary environment, if you're on welfare or pensions, you're getting indexed. So the people I'm more worried about are the people that are on low incomes. They're earning low incomes, and they're renting.
What would surprise me most? There's a few things. I was really interested in Leah's comments earlier about people trading down. I know from listening to some of these charities and not-for-profits we speak to, that issues to do with children going to school without breakfasts is a big issue, which worries me. I'm conscious as well that what people are doing in order to... So if people do actually have a mortgage, what they might be doing to ensure they continue to meet their mortgages, and that's often cutting back on things like food. It might be that they don't meet various bills, including electricity bills and water bills, those sorts of things.
So, I don't know if it would surprise me, but they're the sorts of things that worry me. And the reason, I come back to inflation, because that is what I am here to address in my job. That's why I worry about inflation, because what inflation is doing is it's putting pressure on households, on families, particularly at the lower end of the income distribution. And what they are having to do, they don't have discretionary expenditure. They are the ones that are having to deal with the cost of living within a budget, and it's a budget of essentials.
So, it probably doesn't answer the question what would surprise me. I guess I've answered the question about what worries me, and that's what worries me.
[Panel discussion continues]
Moderator
Looking ahead and when we consider these shocks, these waves of change, I'm interested to hear from each of you what success looks like. What's the goal here? Because that might be reassuring to the audience, but also just to the Australian people. Michele, what does it look like if we get this right?
Michele Bullock
Low and stable inflation, it looks like to me. There's a number of things, but let me say three. One, if in 10 years' time we've got low and stable inflation and we've got a labour market that has adjusted to the potential impacts of AI. So that for me reflects my mandate, and they're important to me. The third thing I would mention is resilience of infrastructure. And this harks back a little bit to the payment system thing. What underlies the economy, what underlies all of this, is the ability to make and receive payments. And for me, the resilience of that infrastructure, if we can, in 10 years' time, say, "Yes, that infrastructure is solid, and it passes tests," particularly with issues to do with AI and cyber and quantum, don't forget quantum, then I think, for us, for me, that will be the three critical things that we will have to have nailed.
[Panel discussion continues]